Beyond Instructions: football coach listening and discussing the game with players

Two players make the same mistake: they receive under pressure, hesitate and lose possession.

One has not recognized the approaching defender. The other has seen the defender but fears being criticized for attempting a forward pass. The action looks similar; the reason behind it may be different.

If the coach gives both players the same instruction, one may improve while the other remains stuck.

This is why effective football coaching requires more than a collection of drills or a louder voice. It requires an understanding of what the player needs, what the situation demands and which coaching response could help.

Understand what you are comparing

The narrative behind this article raises questions about existential, solution-focused, psychodynamic and Gestalt coaching. These approaches come from a broader coaching literature; they are not football formations or session formats.

They also sit at a different level from labels such as performance coaching, developmental coaching, life coaching and career coaching. An approach describes the lens or process used. A context describes where coaching takes place. A purpose describes what it is trying to achieve.

A career conversation can use solution-focused questions. A performance conversation can explore values. A developmental session can combine direct instruction with reflection.

The football examples below are practical adaptations of these ideas, rather than claims that using a particular question makes someone a trained practitioner in that approach.

Performance coaching and developmental coaching: different emphasis, connected responsibilities

Performance coaching emphasizes executing effectively against present demands. A coach preparing for Saturday may focus on escaping the opponent’s press, defending a particular set play or improving the timing of the front line’s pressure.

Developmental coaching emphasizes expanding capability over time. The same coach may want players to recognize pressure independently, solve unfamiliar problems and adapt when an opponent changes shape.

Consider a fullback who repeatedly receives facing their own goal.

A performance intervention might be: “In this situation, open your position before the pass so you can see the winger and the inside support.” It addresses a specific action needed now.

A developmental intervention might be: “What did you know before receiving? How would your position change if the defender approached from the other side?” It helps the player understand and transfer the decision.

Neither purpose belongs exclusively to one age group. Senior players still develop. Young players still need help performing. The tension is how immediate demands influence the opportunities offered to learn.

A youth coach who solves every problem from the touchline may get a more organized performance while leaving players dependent on instructions. A coach who offers exploration without enough guidance may leave inexperienced players unsure what they are trying to achieve.

Connect the two: teach a useful action, help the player understand it, then test whether they can adapt it.

Directive coaching: make the message clear

Directive coaching supplies an instruction, demonstration or correction. It is valuable when a player lacks essential information, an activity needs organizing or a short, specific cue can resolve confusion.

For example: “When our striker presses the centre-back, our nearest midfielder closes the pass into their pivot.” Demonstrate the relationship, then let the players experience it against opposition.

The strength is clarity. The limitation appears when instruction becomes constant control. If every movement depends on the coach’s command, players may struggle when the picture changes faster than instructions can arrive.

Use a clear cue, allow a meaningful attempt and observe what follows. More explanation is useful only if it addresses the actual difficulty.

Non-directive coaching: help the player interpret the game

A more non-directive conversation invites the player to examine their experience and propose a response. The coach remains responsible for the learning environment and can still guide the discussion.

Ask: “Where was the pressure coming from?” “Which teammate could see forward?” “What changed when you carried the ball?”

These questions can reveal information a coach cannot infer from the outcome alone. A lost pass might reflect a poor decision, inaccurate execution or a receiver who stopped moving.

Questioning also has limitations. Players may not yet have the knowledge to answer. A vague question may produce a guess. Too many interruptions can disrupt the game. Asking a question while rejecting every answer except your preferred wording can become instruction disguised as discovery.

Listen, clarify and return to play. Give information when it is needed, then invite players to test its usefulness. FIFA’s guidance on telling and asking supports selecting between these interventions according to the learning situation [1].

A solution-focused lens: find what works and build the next step

Solution-focused coaching pays attention to the desired future, existing resources and occasions when the difficulty is less pronounced [2]. In football, that suggests looking beyond a catalogue of errors.

A midfielder says: “I always lose it when someone presses me.”

Instead of agreeing with the label, explore an exception: “You kept the ball twice in the second half. What was different?”

The player may identify earlier scanning, a closer supporting teammate or a first touch away from pressure. Turn that into a specific experiment: “In the next game, check the nearest pressure before the pass travels and look for your supporting option.”

The value is a manageable next action grounded in something the player has already done. The limitation is oversimplification if a coach overlooks a technical gap, unrealistic task or wider team problem. A positive conversation does not replace accurate analysis.

An existential lens: connect football actions with values and responsibility

An existential perspective explores meaning, choice, responsibility and how a person responds to uncertainty. A football adaptation might help a player consider what kind of teammate they want to be when circumstances become difficult.

A captain wants to lead but withdraws after making a mistake. Ask: “What does leadership mean to you when you are disappointed with your own performance?”

The conversation can move toward an action the captain chooses: communicate the next defensive priority, encourage a teammate or organize the restart.

This may connect behaviour with a personally meaningful standard. It should not become an abstract lecture or an excuse to demand private disclosures. Keep the discussion relevant, age-appropriate and connected to an observable football responsibility.

A Gestalt-informed lens: notice the present experience

A Gestalt perspective emphasizes awareness of present experience and the relationship between the person and their environment. A practical football conversation might explore what the player noticed in a particular moment rather than immediately explaining it for them.

A winger stops communicating after an unsuccessful dribble. Ask: “What did you notice about your attention and your connection with teammates after that action?”

Then use a small experiment: replay a comparable situation and ask the winger to reconnect with support after the first action, whether it succeeds or fails.

Observation, experience and review can make a pattern visible. This is not a basis for interpreting body language as proof of hidden emotions. The player’s account matters, and the coach should remain open to a different explanation.

A psychodynamic lens: consider patterns without inventing explanations

Psychodynamic coaching attends to patterns in relationships and the possible influence of processes outside immediate awareness. That is a specialist approach; football coaches should avoid diagnosing a player’s history or motives.

The useful everyday reminder is to investigate before labeling. A player who becomes defensive during feedback may have misunderstood the message, felt embarrassed by its public delivery or disagreed with the observation.

Ask: “How did you understand what I said?” Then consider your own contribution: tone, timing, setting and previous interactions.

A repeated behaviour deserves curiosity. It does not give the coach permission to invent a psychological explanation. Concerns requiring specialist support should follow the club’s appropriate support arrangements.

Active listening makes the approach usable

The best question has little value if the coach is already preparing the next speech.

Active listening means giving the player time, checking your understanding and using their answer to shape the next response. “You saw the forward pass but thought losing it would mean being substituted. Have I understood you correctly?” is more useful than assuming the player lacked vision.

Listening does not require abandoning standards. You can acknowledge the player’s interpretation and clarify the expectation: “We want you to recognize that forward opportunity. Let’s agree the cues that make the risk worthwhile.”

In workshops, use the same process with coaches. Ask what they observed, what they intended and what they would change. Do not assess their understanding only by whether they repeat the tutor’s language.

Make reflection lead to another attempt

A workshop should connect experience with action. Invite a coach to present a real football problem, design a practice, deliver it, hear peer observations and revise one feature.

For example, a coach wants players to scan more often. Peers notice that the practice has predictable passes and no changing pressure. The next step is to introduce meaningful opposition and observe whether players gather information to solve it.

Reflection becomes useful when it changes the next learning experience. FIFA’s coach-educator examples show active participation and reflective tasks as practical elements of adult learning [3].

For younger players, use simpler language and shorter reflection periods. For coaches, draw on their experience while inviting them to question habits that experience may have reinforced.

Try a mixed approach in your next session

Choose one football problem and follow this sequence:

  1. Observe: Identify the action and its context before explaining the cause.
  2. Clarify: Give essential information or demonstrate the relationship if needed.
  3. Ask: Explore what the player saw and intended.
  4. Listen: Check your understanding without supplying their answer.
  5. Test: Agree one adjustment and return to a realistic game situation.
  6. Review: Examine whether the adjustment helped and what needs to change next.

If the players keep losing possession after a regain, begin with one clear principle: secure the ball and offer distinct supporting options. Ask the regainer what pressure they saw. Ask supporting players which options they created. Test an adjustment in the next repetition.

You may discover that the solution requires a better pass, an earlier supporting movement, a clearer expectation about risk—or all three.

Effective football coaching is a relationship between expertise, observation, conversation and experience. The coach provides direction while helping players become increasingly able to interpret and influence the game themselves.

Before your next intervention, ask: what does this player need to understand or experience to make a better decision next time?

Further reading

This article is an original football application of the distinctions raised in the supplied narrative. It does not reproduce the source passage or endorse one psychological approach as universally superior.

[1] FIFA Training Centre, *When to tell and when to ask*: https://www.fifatrainingcentre.com/en/environment/coaching-competencies/when-to-tell-and-when-to-ask.php

[2] *The Coaching Psychology Handbook*, chapter overview, *Solution-Focused Coaching*: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/9781394292806.ch35

[3] FIFA Training Centre, *Coach Educator demo session: Adopting adult learning principles*: https://www.fifatrainingcentre.com/en/environment/practical-example/coaching-development/the-coach-educator/coach-educator-demo-session-using-adult-learning-principles.php

Background: SAGE, *The Complete Handbook of Coaching*: https://study.sagepub.com/coxhandbook3e/student-resources/about-the-book

Explore more coaching articles →