
A young player can explain a formation, debate the best central attacking midfielder and describe how they won a virtual World Cup. Later, that same player receives in midfield without checking behind, moves into a teammate’s passing lane and presses alone while the team remains deep.
Does the player understand tactics?
Possibly. But the coach needs to establish what that understanding allows the player to do when the controller disappears.
Football video games create an interesting coaching opportunity. They can give players a reason to discuss formations, roles, risk and opposition behaviour. They can also make tactical language sound more complete than the player’s ability to recognize and solve the same problem on grass.
The challenge for coaches is to connect the conversation to the performance.
Are We Coaching the Player—or Arguing with the Vocabulary?
“Coach, I’m a CM.”
“We need a CAM.”
“Why don’t we play a higher press?”
These comments can sound different from the language a coach grew up using. They do not automatically reveal poor understanding. Abbreviations such as CB, FB and CM are established football shorthand; games did not invent them. Coaches also use labels such as “six,” “eight” and “ten,” whose meanings vary between teams and countries.
The useful question is what sits behind the label.
When a player says “CM,” ask:
- Where can you help the ball carrier?
- What information do you need before receiving?
- When should you support underneath and when should you threaten beyond?
- Who protects the space if you move forward?
- What changes immediately after we lose possession?
A position becomes meaningful when the player connects it to responsibilities, teammates and changing information.
Knowing where a position appears on a formation screen is a starting point. Knowing how to make that position useful is a development task.
The Biggest Difference May Be the Camera
In many football game modes, the operator has an elevated view and additional information such as a radar. Settings vary, but the player can often see relationships that a real footballer must discover while moving.
The midfielder on the pitch has to locate the defender behind, judge the approaching pass, update the position of a teammate and prepare the first touch. Meanwhile, the picture continues changing.
The gamer may see the far-side winger immediately. The footballer must first gather enough information to know that the winger is available.
Then comes execution. Selecting a pass with a controller is a skill within that environment. Delivering it on grass requires suitable balance, contact, timing and ball speed under pressure.
Seeing the answer from above and finding the answer from inside the game are different tasks.
That distinction should shape our coaching. If a player can explain a switch of play but rarely attempts one, investigate whether the difficulty is scanning, receiving orientation, passing technique, teammate availability or recognition of the moment. “You should know this from FIFA” does not solve any of those problems.
Winning a Virtual Tournament Deserves Respect—and a Football Test
Players may still call EA’s football series “FIFA,” although it moved to the EA SPORTS FC name in 2023. A “World Cup challenge” might mean an in-game tournament, a self-created competition or an official esports event. Ask what the player actually means.
Winning can involve anticipation, adaptation, concentration and learning how an opponent behaves. Those achievements deserve recognition within their setting.
However, a successful virtual strategy may partly depend on a particular game’s mechanics. A route that reliably beats software-controlled defenders may close against independent opponents. A pressing instruction may change avatar behaviour immediately; a live team must coordinate pressure, cover and recovery through communication and physical action.
Ask the player to show one winning decision, then explore it:
What made it work? Which information did you have? What would you need to find for yourself on the pitch? What would your teammates have to do?
This keeps curiosity alive while testing the football claim.
What Does the Research Actually Tell Us?
The evidence deserves more care than either “gaming makes players tactically smarter” or “gaming is ruining football.”
A 2025 study by Imanian and colleagues randomly assigned 40 male physical-education undergraduates, previously unfamiliar with FIFA, to game and non-game groups. The gaming group performed better on planning and decision-making tests. Those outcomes were cognitive tasks—the Tower of London and Iowa Gambling Task. They were not tests of academy players’ tactical performance in matches. [1]
A separate study by Fortes and colleagues used a randomized crossover design with 25 male professional footballers. Passing decisions in a simulated match were poorer after the smartphone and video-game conditions than after the control condition. This raises questions about demanding screen activity before performance; it does not establish permanent harm from gaming or a universal screen-time limit for young players. [2]
Different populations, timings and outcomes can produce different findings. Neither study settles whether ordinary football gaming improves live tactical understanding in Gen Z youth players.
For coaches, the sensible response is to observe the player and test a specific connection. Treat the following ideas as coaching applications to explore, rather than a proven gaming intervention.
Do Coaches Feel the Effect?
Some coaches may recognize players who arrive with confident tactical opinions, strong preferences about positions or expectations shaped partly by games. That is a possibility to investigate in your squad, not evidence that an entire generation behaves alike.
The same question can represent very different needs.
“Why am I not playing as a CAM?” might mean:
- I want to understand my responsibility.
- I feel more confident receiving near goal.
- I believe a role label should guarantee certain freedoms.
- I have noticed a genuine space we are failing to use.
A dismissive response can close a useful conversation. An uncritical response can allow an incomplete idea to become a team instruction.
Try: “Show me what you want that player to do. Then show me how the opponent could stop it.”
Gen Z is a broad cohort, not a coaching diagnosis. Players differ in gaming access, football experience, personality and learning needs. Some younger players in today’s programmes also fall outside conventional Gen Z boundaries. Coach the person in front of you.
Competitive Intensity Is Not the Same as Match Readiness
A young person can be deeply invested in a virtual match. Concentration, frustration and excitement may be obvious. Those feelings do not reproduce the running, braking, contact and technical demands of live football.
Be precise when discussing intensity. Emotional arousal, mental effort and physical workload are different things.
If gaming becomes part of a readiness conversation, ask about the actual routine. Is a late session displacing sleep opportunity? Is the player arriving distracted or poorly prepared? Or is gaming a recreational activity that fits comfortably around responsibilities?
Work with players and families on preparation habits. Avoid turning enthusiasm for games into an accusation about commitment.
Build a Bridge from Screen to Pitch
Use a simple sequence:
Describe → Translate → Recreate → Test → Reflect
1. Describe. Ask the player to explain one decision from a game. Keep the focus narrow: finding the spare player, switching play or protecting a turnover.
2. Translate. State the football principle in shared language. Separate the principle from any assistance supplied by the interface or software.
3. Recreate. Design an opposed practice containing the relevant relationships. Give defenders freedom to respond and attackers more than one solution.
4. Test. Remove the original reminder or special condition. Observe whether the player recognizes a similar opportunity in normal play.
5. Reflect. Compare what the player explained, noticed, executed and adapted. Agree the next development need.
A console is optional. A drawing or suitable match clip can introduce the same problem, allowing players without gaming access to participate equally.
A Practical Example: Can the CM Find the Free Player?
Organization: Play 4v4 plus two neutral players in approximately 32 × 26 metres, with two mini-goals at each end. Neutrals support the team in possession and cannot score. Begin with one central neutral and one outside neutral; rotate roles between bouts. Use unlimited touches and immediate transitions. Adjust space to the players.
First bout: Play for three minutes with minimal intervention. Observe the central player’s information gathering and supporting angles.
Brief discussion: Ask, “Before the pass arrives, how can you know whether to turn, set or play across?”
Second bout: Repeat the game. Look for purposeful checking, movement out of a defender’s cover shadow and an appropriate next action. A protected set may be a better decision than a turn into pressure.
Transfer bout: Change to 5v5 without neutrals. Observe whether the same player can recognize pressure when no longer operating with protected supporting status.
Review four things separately:
- Could the player explain the option?
- Did the player recognize when it appeared?
- Could the player execute it?
- Did the player adapt when the opponent closed it?
A completed pass alone does not answer all four questions. Neither does an unsuccessful pass automatically mean the decision was poor. Revisit the behaviour in later training and matches before claiming lasting transfer.
The Coach’s Challenge: Replace Assumptions with Evidence
For the next two weeks, collect examples rather than opinions about a generation.
Choose one tactical concept a player discusses confidently. Observe it in normal training. Explore the player’s explanation, design a related game and check what happens when your prompts disappear. Include examples where the player’s idea helps the team.
Be ready to discover that a fluent explanation hides a practical difficulty. Be equally ready to discover that a quiet player understands the situation through movement better than through words.
Our own preferred formations and coaching phrases also need testing. Experience does not protect a coach from mistaking familiar language for clear understanding.
They Know the Buttons. Can We Help Them Read the Picture?
Football games may provide interest, vocabulary and a starting point for tactical discussion. Players still need opportunities to gather information, coordinate with teammates, execute under pressure and learn from changing situations.
The coach who dismisses the screen may miss a route into learning. The coach who assumes screen success guarantees football intelligence may miss the learning that remains.
Invite the explanation. Examine the situation. Put the idea into an opposed game. Review what the player can do independently.
Respect the gaming skill. Test the football understanding. Coach the connection.
A Question for Your Next Session
Ask your players: “What do you understand easily in a football video game that feels harder to recognize when you are actually playing?”
Their answers may tell you more about your next practice than another debate about formations.
Sources and Further Reading
- Imanian et al. (2025), Training of the eSport FIFA enhances cognitive performance of planning and decision making in cognitive tests. Institutional abstract: https://fis.dshs-koeln.de/en/publications/training-of-the-esport-fifa-enhances-cognitive-performanceof-plan/
- Fortes et al. (2020), The effect of smartphones and playing video games on decision-making in soccer players: A crossover and randomised study. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31941416/
- Electronic Arts (2023), EA SPORTS FC 24 Launches Worldwide Today. https://news.ea.com/press-releases/press-releases-details/2023/EA-SPORTS-FC-24-Launches-Worldwide-Today---A-New-Era-Begins-for-the-Worlds-Game/default.aspx
Research summaries above draw on the published abstracts. Practice proposals and fictional examples are coaching applications, not findings from those studies. This independent article is not affiliated with FIFA or EA SPORTS.
Explore more free articles and practical coach education at Game Changer Coaching Library.
